If a 20-lb grill tank is empty before an I-70 / I-65 trip or a Keystone cookout, Maps often sends you to a locked cage in a grocery or big-box lot on 86th, Washington, or US 31. That cage is usually an exchange: you leave your cylinder and take a different, prefilled one. A refill puts propane into your tank — attendant or pay-at-pump — billed for gallons added.
This page is for Indianapolis, Greenwood, Plainfield, Noblesville, Whitestown, and Lawrence people who want that refill: U-Haul stations whose location pages say Tank Refills, and Tractor Supply stores whose pages list propane tank refill. Collar-county TSC rows are here so this is not a downtown-only table. It is not a price board. Call before you drive. Louisville / Jeffersonville is a different page. Bloomington stays off this table.
How refill differs from exchange
Indianapolis-area U-Haul refill pages state that refilling is cheaper than exchange and that exchange does not credit leftover propane in the tank you turn in. Gallon prices on those pages change; omitted from cards. Shadeland and Eastgate also list 20-lb exchange next to tank refills — ask for refill if that is what you want.
Verified refill locations (Indianapolis metro)
Only stations with a public page that describes refill (not exchange-only). Hours below are office / store / published fill hours from those pages — propane attendant coverage can be shorter; call ahead. Gallon prices are omitted; they change.
Pins mark stations we could place from the listed street address. Click a pin to jump to that card. Stations without a pin still list below.
Jump: Shadeland / East · Keystone · Michigan Rd / North · Southern Plaza · Eastgate · Eagledale / Lafayette · Lawrence · Southeast / Atlantis · Greenwood · Plainfield · Noblesville · Whitestown
Shadeland / East
Shadeland / East
U-Haul
2701 N Shadeland Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill and exchange; 20-lb exchange is listed next to tank refills. Landmark on the page: N Of I-70, at the railroad tracks.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 546-1503
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Keystone
Keystone
U-Haul
5251 N Keystone Ave, Indianapolis, IN 46220
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill; propane exchange not listed in the services bullets when checked. Landmark on the page: N Of Fall Crk Pkwy, close to 52nd St.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 257-4291
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Michigan Rd / North
Michigan Rd / North
U-Haul
6014 Michigan Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46228
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill; propane exchange not listed in the services bullets when checked. Landmark on the page: N Of Kessler and close to 60th St, across from Dollar General.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 257-5461
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Southern Plaza
Southern Plaza
U-Haul
4011 S East St, Indianapolis, IN 46227
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill; propane exchange not listed in the services bullets when checked. Landmark on the page: N Of I-465, Corner of East St (Rt31) and Hanna St - Southern Plaza.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 787-6368
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Eastgate
Eastgate
U-Haul
7425 E Washington St, Indianapolis, IN 46219
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill and exchange; 20-lb exchange is listed next to tank refills. Landmark on the page: E Washington / US 40 east side.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 899-9990
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Eagledale / Lafayette
Eagledale / Lafayette
U-Haul
2960 Lafayette Rd, Indianapolis, IN 46222
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill; propane exchange not listed in the services bullets when checked. Landmark on the page: Lafayette Rd @ 30th, across from Speedway Gas.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 923-1508
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Lawrence
Lawrence
U-Haul
6800 Pendleton Pike, Indianapolis, IN 46226
Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Office hours (published on this location’s U-Haul page): Mon–Thu 7am–7pm; Fri 7am–8pm; Sat 7am–7pm; Sun 9am–5pm. Call ahead for the pump.
- Tank sizes
- ~3–100 lb portable (page text); also lists RVs, campers, forklift tanks, autogas
- RV
- Yes (page lists RVs/campers)
- Pay-at-pump
- Yes (page lists “Propane pay at pump”)
- Also on page
- Page title is refill; propane exchange not listed in the services bullets when checked. Landmark on the page: Pendleton Pike and 38th St, Behind Advance Auto in the old Menard's building.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 829-6030
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Southeast / Atlantis
Southeast / Atlantis
Tractor Supply
8815 South Atlantis Drive, Indianapolis, IN 46239
Store hours: unknown on this pass — call ahead
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Store hours: unknown on this pass (official store page listed propane tank refill). Propane attendant hours: not published on the store page — call ahead (staff fill; TSC process is not listed as pay-at-pump).
- Tank sizes
- Unknown on this store page. TSC company propane-refill page says tanks up to 100 lb, including RV tanks, sold by the gallon — confirm at the store.
- RV
- Unknown at this store (TSC company FAQ: majority of stores fill RVs; call ahead).
- Pay-at-pump
- Unknown / not listed as pay-at-pump (staff fill).
- Also on page
- Service listed: Propane tank refill.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 862-1013
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Greenwood
Greenwood
Tractor Supply
1460 South US 31, Greenwood, IN 46143
Store hours: unknown on this pass — call ahead
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Store hours: unknown on this pass (official store page listed propane tank refill). Propane attendant hours: not published on the store page — call ahead (staff fill; TSC process is not listed as pay-at-pump).
- Tank sizes
- Unknown on this store page. TSC company propane-refill page says tanks up to 100 lb, including RV tanks, sold by the gallon — confirm at the store.
- RV
- Unknown at this store (TSC company FAQ: majority of stores fill RVs; call ahead).
- Pay-at-pump
- Unknown / not listed as pay-at-pump (staff fill).
- Also on page
- Service listed: Propane tank refill.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 882-5800
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Plainfield
Plainfield
Tractor Supply
129 North Perry Rd, Plainfield, IN 46168
Store hours: unknown on this pass — call ahead
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Store hours: unknown on this pass (official store page listed propane tank refill). Propane attendant hours: not published on the store page — call ahead (staff fill; TSC process is not listed as pay-at-pump).
- Tank sizes
- Unknown on this store page. TSC company propane-refill page says tanks up to 100 lb, including RV tanks, sold by the gallon — confirm at the store.
- RV
- Unknown at this store (TSC company FAQ: majority of stores fill RVs; call ahead).
- Pay-at-pump
- Unknown / not listed as pay-at-pump (staff fill).
- Also on page
- Service listed: Propane tank refill.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 839-4792
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Noblesville
Noblesville
Tractor Supply
2375 East Pleasant St Rte 37 South, Noblesville, IN 46060
Store hours: unknown on this pass — call ahead
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Store hours: unknown on this pass (official store page listed propane tank refill). Propane attendant hours: not published on the store page — call ahead (staff fill; TSC process is not listed as pay-at-pump).
- Tank sizes
- Unknown on this store page. TSC company propane-refill page says tanks up to 100 lb, including RV tanks, sold by the gallon — confirm at the store.
- RV
- Unknown at this store (TSC company FAQ: majority of stores fill RVs; call ahead).
- Pay-at-pump
- Unknown / not listed as pay-at-pump (staff fill).
- Also on page
- Service listed: Propane tank refill.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 776-1883
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Whitestown
Whitestown
Tractor Supply
4131 S Indianapolis Rd, Whitestown, IN 46075
Store hours: unknown on this pass — call ahead
Report closed / wrong hours
Details
- Hours
- Store hours: unknown on this pass (official store page listed propane tank refill). Propane attendant hours: not published on the store page — call ahead (staff fill; TSC process is not listed as pay-at-pump).
- Tank sizes
- Unknown on this store page. TSC company propane-refill page says tanks up to 100 lb, including RV tanks, sold by the gallon — confirm at the store.
- RV
- Unknown at this store (TSC company FAQ: majority of stores fill RVs; call ahead).
- Pay-at-pump
- Unknown / not listed as pay-at-pump (staff fill).
- Also on page
- Service listed: Propane tank refill.
- Last verified
- 2026-09-03 (source page checked)
(317) 769-3105
· Google Maps
· Apple Maps
· Source
Not listed (on purpose): grocery / big-box Blue Rhino–style cages unless a page explicitly says they also refill. U-Haul / TSC Bloomington, Columbus IN, and Lafayette IN (the city) are other metros. Jeffersonville / Sellersburg sit on the Louisville page. Live gallon prices change; omitted from cards.
What to check before you drive
- Refill ≠ exchange. If the pin is only a cage with a card reader and no attendant fill, you are in exchange territory. Shadeland and Eastgate U-Haul list refill and exchange — say refill.
- Call ahead. Ask: “Do you refill my tank today, what sizes, and is someone available now?” Tractor Supply refill depends on staff.
- Bring the empty (or low) tank you own. Refill keeps your cylinder; exchange swaps it.
- Read the collar date. DOT cylinders must be requalified within 12 years of manufacture (then again per method).
- Look for OPD. Cylinders up through 40 lb propane capacity generally need an Overfill Prevention Device valve.
- Condition matters. Excessive rust/pitting, dents/bulges/cuts, damaged collar/footring, or a bad valve.
- Expect a partial “full.” Legal fill leaves vapor space (~80%).
- RV / I-70 / I-65. Ask whether they fill RV ASME tanks — U-Haul pages list RVs/campers; TSC store pages do not state RV fill (company FAQ says many stores do — call).
Call-ahead script
“Hi — I’m looking to refill my own tank, not exchange. Do you refill today? What sizes? Do you fill RVs? Is someone at the pump now?”
Common rejection rules (cite, don’t invent)
From U.S. DOT / PHMSA consumer guide Is Your Cylinder Safe to Fill? (PDF):
- Do not fill cylinders with excessive rust/corrosion/pitting, dents/bulges/cuts/cracks, missing/damaged footring, neckring/collar, or valve cover, or leaking/defective valve or relief device.
- Check manufacture / requalification dates; cylinders must be requalified within 12 years of manufacture (then per marking — e.g. “E” visual often means 5 years).
From North Carolina Department of Agriculture & Consumer Services LP-Gas consumer FAQ (plain-language industry practice summary; same DOT/OPD themes) (page): turn-downs include out-of-date collar, missing required OPD (cylinders up to and including 40 lb), damage/corrosion, loose/damaged collar or foot ring, damaged valve.
Sources